When Equal Doesn’t Equal Equal

October 22, 2009 at 10:15 PM | In Gay Rights | 1 Comment

One of my main reasons for beginning my blog was to become another voice for Marriage Equality in America – to be a proponent for the passage of gay marriage laws in every state. Though this issue is important enough to talk about all day, every day, I thought it would be best to bring up these points when something particularly interesting comes my way.

Today I came across a slew of videos shot of Maine citizens making arguments for and against a state Marriage Equality law back in April 2009. Most of the two to three minute speeches were beautiful, and to me, undebatable.

My praise for these brave speech-makers could constitute several posts in and of itself. However, the pride in me was let down when I came across an anti-marriage equality campaign video telling the story of “The Parker Family,” a family whose son “was taught to accept same-sex marriage” by way of a “diversity bookbag” sent home with him in Kindergarden. The reporter and the parents call the message in the bookbag – a one page anecdote about “Clifford and [his] partner, Henry,” who constitute a family.

While the campaign video expresses shock and heavy dismay, the characters never really explain what is so bad about teaching children to “affirm these relationships.” Apparently, these messages “really confuse kids.” I want to know what the campaign is really saying. Is this nuclear family with sad music playing in the background suggesting that homosexuality is a choice, and that their children can become gay through the “indoctrination” by their Kindergarden teachers? Why should these parents be notified by the school before these “types of things” are taught?

It seems to me that gay marriage is hugely oversexualized and clearly misunderstood by the general public – as this type of message was responsible for the passing of Proposition 8 and countless other amendments country-wide. When do children learn about love? When are they taught that they can achieve all their dreams? Is that when they also learn that only some of them can achieve their dreams of marrying the person they love? Or is that a harsher, more crushing reality that comes later on, when their parents decide it’s time?

This, folks, is propaganda. It is one side of an issue that exaggerates and clearly misinforms for a political agenda. I could go on and on here, but I think I’ll just let you watch the video.

1 Comment »

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. I’ve been thinking about same-sex marriage a lot lately due to the fact that the equal rights march just took place in DC two weeks ago. As someone who has always been an advocate for same-sex marriage, I’ve begun to change my tone and idea toward the entire institution. The gay rights movement is all about sexual and societal liberation and is a coup de tat against traditional forms of patriarchy and oppression— therefore I’m lead to question the message behind assimilating gay couples into marriage which is a historically oppressive institution. Until 1967 interracial marriage was illegal in Virginia, and other states unspecified, and in the past marriage represented the loss of legal status for women in order to be subsumed by their husband. Therefore, legalizing marriage for homosexuals only serves to reinforce an oppressive institution that marginalizes those that are counter to traditional Lutheran and Catholic religious ideals. It’s my opinion that marriage should be completely removed from our constitution and be replace with civil unions available to all. This way people can reap the government benefits of a marriage, but it is done in a secular way. If people want a marriage, go to your church and obtain one. But to legally send the message that these traditional ideals of what marriage constitutes is what the entire American public believes in and lawfully follows is against the very ideas of liberty that are in our preamble.


Leave a comment

XHTML: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.